Illusory Victory

Wednesday, May 04, 2011

{source: The Telegraph}
"For me, this type of celebration would have been justifiable in only two circumstances: 1) if we had captured Bin Laden or 2) if we had somehow managed to “win” the war (ha). This event may have provided “closure” to some, but it’s essentially illusory– and we’re admitting this fact when we say it was a “symbolic victory.” Killing Bin Laden doesn’t hammer any nail into the terrorist coffin– in fact, I think it’s safe to say things are going to be even more volatile now than they were before. Someone else is going to try extra hard to step up to the plate in his absence.

And… killing Bin Laden doesn’t change the fact that we are fighting wars for extremely questionable reasons. Or the fact that we are fighting enemies that can’t ever be fully defeated.

I respect the vigils. I would have had more respect for the cheering and singing and the drunken antics if we had captured the man rather than put a bullet through his head. As it stands, all we are really celebrating is someone’s death (and for the record, I’m not one of those people who is saying, “he was a person too, it’s horrible to celebrate anyone’s death”– he was a bad guy. I’m not sad about it. But there’s still something morbid about the whole ordeal). If it feels like closure, it’s because it’s vengeance. It’s not because we won anything. We’re celebrating like we won because there isn’t going to be another V-J Day at the end of this thing (if we ever get there). There is no closure in this type of war– we’re celebrating because we know there won’t be a celebration.

(and because we want to feel like we did when Obama got elected)

But maybe I’m just cynical."

Reader comment from NYU Local

5 comments:

Esra said...

Totally agree here Sha. Far too much fuss has been made over this, and there are bigger issues at stake than the life of one man. Great post!

RS said...

I agree. This 'victory' is no more than an illusion. What scares me is, this may be the beginning of something even more horrid.

=(

Anonymous said...

I mourn the loss of thousands of precious lives, but I will not rejoice in the death of one, not even an enemy. Returning hate for hate multiplies hate, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars. Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that."--

Nubenegra said...

I do really hate all this stuff. It smells so bad... The version has just changed twice in the first 24 hours of the pretended death of Bin Laden. It's been an execution, if it was him, of course. No body, no dead man. I fear that this is only the beggining, but not of what they're saying: "a violent rise up of islamic terrorism". I think they have just open the door to new occidental invasions. Let's look at Pakistan because there it is the clue.
Kind regards,

Verónica

Halima said...

Makes sense to me
it hurts the head to try and understand/comprehend things like the questions/points you raised
like how civilians in Iraq and Afghanistan are mindlessly murdered over the deacde
but he's found in Pakistan.
will they ever see true justice or receive even an apology from the world "superpower ? "
good post & great blog :) .
xxx